Fall Try-On Haul: Shoes, Tops & Dresses
Greetings and salutations! It’s time for my weekly try-on haul. This one is chock full of fall shoes (mostly snake print) #sorrynotsorry, as well as a smattering of tops and dresses.
The usual disclaimers apply — I’m 5’5″ with a slightly hourglass shape, and I usually wear small tops and a 6 or 8 in pants. My average dress size is an 8, but depending on the brand, I have everything in my closet from 4 to 12. #vanitysizingisreal
Try-On Haul: Fall Tops
Let’s start with tops! Links and descriptions are below the pictures, and I’m also sharing whether I kept or returned each item.
J.Crew Leopard Teddie sweater (size small) // I had last year’s version of this sweater, and I loved it. I wore it a ton — both alone and as a base layer with my leather jacket — and I can see myself doing the same with this one.
Besides the print, I really like the fit and feel of this sweater. It is form-fitting without being clingy, and it’s nice and soft. It’s also a great price!
(If you’re wondering why I’m keeping this when I have last year’s similar one, it’s because people like it when I can link to the exact item I’m wearing; and I really like this year’s print!)
Lucky Brand Crew Neck Camo Tee (size small) // This tee is wonderfully soft and thin (but not too thin.) I wanted to love it, but the crewneck just doesn’t do anything for me. I know some of you love crewnecks, so if you’re a fan of crewnecks and camo, this one may be for you!
Gibson x Living in Yellow City Safari Scalloped V-Neck Tank (size small) // I liked this top so much when I saw Cyndi style it that I ordered one for myself… along with the halter version below.
Pros: The print is gorgeous, the scalloped v-neck adds interest and is a modest cut, and it pairs nicely with white or black pants (and blue jeans too.)
Cons: The material is a bit stiff. I’d like it more if it had a better drape.
VERDICT: I’m holding onto this one for a while to see if I end up reaching for it; I always keep tags on until I wear things for the first time.
Gibson x City Safari Tara Gibson Halter Top (size small) // The same pretty print, but it fits really weirdly around the bust and arm openings.
James Perse Women’s Deep V-Neck Tee (size 2) // I’m always on the lookout for a good classic white tee, and they aren’t as easy to find as one might think. After seeing James Perse tees touted as some of the best by several fashion bloggers I follow, I decided to see what all the fuss is about. Happily, I found one on sale at Nordstrom Rack! (It’s also on Amazon.)
In a nutshell: I LOVE THIS TEE. The fabric has that trendy slub texture, and it’s thin but not so thin that it’s see-through. It also has a great drape through the midsection.
The scoopneck is flattering, and while it’s borderline too low, I think it will be okay after the first washing. It has a straight hemline and no boob pocket. Also, the sleeve length is just right. It is perfect for layering or wearing alone. I have it layered under a cardigan here…
VERDICT: keeping! I’ve already worn it twice. Totally on the James Perse bandwagon now. I just hope I don’t end up wishing I’d sized up to a 3 after I wash it. I’ll keep you posted.
Free People Sienna Snap Cuff Cotton Blend Tee (size small) // This top was a discovery from my Facebook Group, and it’s a really nice piece for fall and transition season because it’s so lightweight. I love the details and the wide v-neck.
Typical for Free People, it runs quite large, so you may want to size down if you don’t want this much drape. It also comes in nice shades of blue, green, red, and white. I was undecided between this black, the red, and the army green. I also love it in white, but I fear that would be too sheer.
VERDICT: I’m debating trying the x-small before making a final decision… also debating a different color.
also wearing: Caslon Crop Utility Pants (highly recommend; size down if in between)
Try-On Haul: Fall Dresses & Skirts
Leith Cap Sleeve Floral Midi Dress size M // This dress has potential, but I think they cut corners to keep it in the price range they watch, so the fit is a little off. If they put in a zipper, it could be more fitted, which would make it more flattering.
I actually like it better from the rear than I do from the front. Because it’s not so fitted, it doesn’t make my hips look quite as wide in proportion to my waist, as the more fitted dresses do. (Keep scrolling to see what I mean.)
The pattern is kind of fun, and I like that faux wrap skirt the asymmetrical hem, so it could be a nice piece for someone. I’m wearing the medium, for size reference.
also wearing: Madewell Addie mules
Boden Penny Jersey Dress (size 8) // I know I shared these last week, but I wanted to show you more angles and give a more detailed review of each.
This dress is similar to their summer one that I loved so much — it has that same fit through the waist and skirt, which is very flattering (at least on me!) It comes in another fun pattern as well as two solids, and the material is substantial.
These would make great work wear dresses, although I wouldn’t wear it with the nude pumps. I feel like it needs a bootie or suede round toe pump.
VERDICT: debating one of the other colors; I don’t have the right footwear for this one, although I like the navy and saffron.
Boden Tilly Ottoman Dress (size 8) // I think this dress is soooo super flattering, and I love the extra length and the back zip details. (Mine isn’t quite zipped up so you’re seeing a little of the contrasting lining.)
The material is so thick and gorgeous, really nice quality. Again, I don’t like my shoes with this; I’d rather see a blockier suede pump or some type of bootie.
VERDICT: Probably returning. While I love it, I don’t think it’s as practical for my life as the other two.
Boden Jasmine Ottoman Dress in Conker size 8 // This is my favorite of the three. It fits like it was made for me, and I think the styling is a lot more practical for my purposes. I would mainly wear this to church, or maybe to a show or something like that.
It would make a nice work wear dress, too, for those of you who work in a school or office setting.
VERDICT: Undecided; I ordered the black to try, and I also want to try this rust with my cognac suede booties before I make up my mind.
also wearing: Sam Edelman Hiltin boots
Boden Jasmine Ottoman Dress in Black size 8 // After I got the rust, I decided I might like it better in a classic black. I like this one too, but the rust is definitely fun for fall. Because of the 3/4 sleeves, I’m not sure I’d wear this all winter anyway, so maybe the rust is the better choice.
VERDICT: Undecided… but definitely keeping one of these. Which gets your vote? Rust or black?
also wearing: Halogen Abbi booties (see more below)
Boden Opal Dress size 8 // This is pretty, and it’s a really neat sweater material that is also fully lined. Again, very nice quality. I just don’t feel it flatters me, and I dno’t have the shoes I’d want with it, plus it’s pretty pricey.
As an aside, isn’t it interesting what a difference footwear makes with an outfit? I think the sweater dress above would be gorgeous with blush pumps — like these in the mauve leather.
I actually had them and returned them because I thought they were too spring/summer and I was afraid I wouldn’t wear them. I’m rethinking that now.
VERDICT: returning, but I think it would be nice on someone.
WHBM Stretch-Satin Sheath Dress size 6 // This dress is made of a nice, thick black satin, and it’s stretch so very comfortable. I think the neckline is super pretty too. It’s simple, but if I hadn’t found the Eliza J side drape sheath for the wedding I’m attending in October, I probably would have kept this one.
VERDICT: returning, but only b/c I don’t need it.
also wearing: Stuart Weitzman Nudistsong sandals (60% off)
WHBM Metallic Draped-Neck Shift Dress size 8 // I think this would be perfect for New Year’s Eve, or perhaps for a wedding in Vegas. (I actually have a friend who just wore something almost identical to this to a Vegas wedding.)
It’s a little much for the wedding I’m attending, but it’s super cute on, and it’s nice quality. I appreciate the weighted cowl neck, and it skims the body nicely.
VERDICT: returning, but only b/c I don’t need it.
AQUA Midi Slip Skirt (size medium) // These silky midi slip skirts are trending right now, and this gorgeous leopard print caught my eye. Unfortunately, the medium was snug on me, so I’ll need to try it again in a large.
My biggest challenge is with how to style these skirts. Most girls are tucking in their tops, but that’s not my best look. I tried it with a traditional v-neck cashmere sweater (above) and I don’t love it… but maybe I should try again with shoes.
VERDICT: exchanging for a large
Try-On Haul: Fall Shoes
I’ve been on a bit of a snake print kick lately . . . pardon the pun! One of the girls in my Facebook Group shared some snake print sneakers she purchased, which sent me on a hunt for a pair of my own.
I originally set out to find a less expensive pair, but I ended up at my local Nordstrom last week and spotted this Vince pair, and I couldn’t resist trying them.
Vince Blair 5 Slip-On Sneaker size 8 // These shoes are insanely comfortable, they’re fully leather lined, and just so luxe. I have narrow heels, and they slip a bit, but not so much that I’m walking out of them.
I like the lower vamp (they don’t come up as high on my foot as the other two, which is generally more slimming) but I’m not crazy about the warm neutral tones. I wear a lot of grey and cool colors, and I’d prefer a pair with cooler color tones.
VERDICT: Undecided. Love the comfort, don’t love the price tag, and the color is holding me back. I’m afraid I won’t get a very good cost per wear out of them.
Steve Madden Gills Platform Slip-On Sneaker in Taupe Snake size 8 // These also have warmer tones, but there’s not quite as much contrast as the Vince pair — which I like. For the price point, they’re comfortable enough.
Unfortunately, I ordered them a half size too small, and when I re-ordered the 8 1/2, I somehow ordered a different color.
Steve Madden Gills in Natural Snake size 8.5 // So in theory, I like this color palette better, but I don’t like the print as much. It looks like two big diamonds on top rather than an all-over print.
And they look kind of clunky on my feet. I guess it’s the platform, but I don’t feel the taupe snake looks quite as clunky, and I like that pattern better.
VERDICT: Undecided, but I think the Maddens are a good purchase if I’m not going to wear snake print sneakers a ton.
Kate Spade New York Ginger Platform Sneakers size 8 // So these… I love the color palette and the pattern to the snake print, and they have a more luxe look than the Maddens, for sure.
You knew there was a but coming, didn’t you??
These shoes are NOT comfortable — they cut into the sides of my foot — and they also have a really high vamp, which I feel makes them look a bit clunky on my thin, flat feet. I should wear them around the house a bit and see if they loosen up at all, but for this price, I want to really love them, so I’ve just been letting them sit and stare at me.
VERDICT: I think I’m going to return them all and order the Steve Madden in Taupe Snake in the right size. At least that way, if I don’t end up wearing them a ton, I won’t be out a chunk of change.
Steve Madden Feather Loafer Flats size 8 // I also ordered these loafers and the mules below. #snakeobsessed
The quality is what you’d expect from Steve Madden. For a trendy shoe, I think it’s a good value. I recommend sizing up half, though, to accommodate the pointy toe.
VERDICT: exchanging for an 8.5
Steve Madden Flavor Flat Mules size 8 // Same story here — decent quality for the price point, cute shoes, on trend, and fairly walkable. I mean, I wouldn’t wear them to the mall all day or anything, but they stay on my feet.
VERDICT: Returning — only because a girl can only wear many snake print shoes, and I like the subtle colors in the loafers better than the mules. Also, the loafers are more walkable.
also wearing: Rag & Bone Dre ankle boyfriend jeans
Splendid Hailee II Snake Embossed Western Mules size 8 // Okay, last pair of snake print shoes . . . I promise! (Today, anyway. Ha!)
These mules are surprisingly comfortable, nice quality, very walkable, and I really like the print. The price is high for a shoe you can only wear in the fall, but I’d say it’s on par with the quality.
VERDICT: undecided. I need to try them on with more outfits and figure out how much I’d really wear them.
Halogen Abbi Block Heel Booties size 8 // Finally, these are the booties I tried on with the black Boden dress above. If you’re looking for a budget-friendly sock bootie that doesn’t have a super skinny shaft, these are a great option.
The 2 3/4″ block heel is very walkable, and they have a flattering shape throughout. The quality isn’t the best, but for sale price, they’re a good value.
VERDICT: I already have sock booties that I love, so I probably won’t keep these for my personal closet, but I wanted to find a pair I can recommend to those looking for this style. I expect they’re going to sell out since they’re on sale, so if you like them, I would grab them now.
Did you like this post?
Subscribe to get email updates! In addition to my most recent blog posts, you’ll receive exclusive newsletter content like special sales, my newest favorite finds, and an occasional peek behind the scenes — all delivered right to your inbox. PLUS you’ll be automatically entered for a chance to win a $100 gift card each month!
This post contains affiliate links. When you shop through my links, it helps support my business (at no additional cost to you) so thank you!