I’ve been slowly updating my shoe lineup for spring, and these are the pairs that ended up in my closet. It’s a mix of practical neutrals, fun textures, and a few trendier styles I just couldn’t resist. Some are already in regular rotation, while others haven’t gotten as much wear as I expected—but each one either filled a gap or gave me something new to try this season.
Reformation Kyla Boat Shoe (8) // J.Crew trench (8) // LOFT stripe sweater (S) // MOTHER Dazzler (30) // FREJA Caroline // Tom Ford sunnies
I realize my shoe shopping habits aren’t exactly typical—I tend to replace at least half my lineup each season—so yes, this is a lot of new shoes by normal standards! But if you’re looking to refresh your shoe collection this season, hopefully this gives you a few ideas.
What’s New in My Spring Shoe Lineup
For reference, I typically wear EU size 39 or US 8 to 8.5 in most shoes and boots. I often size up a half or full size in running sneakers, and occasionally size down a half size in sandals—especially slides and mules.
I’ve had my fair share of foot issues over the years, so I tend to look for shoes with some support or a bit of a heel. That said, I’ll still make an exception for a cute flat sandal—I just save those for days when I won’t be doing a ton of walking.
Okay, without further ado (and in no particular order), here are the shoes I added to my closet this spring!
Jeffrey Campbell Boast Boat Shoes in Camel Brush
at Anthropologie // at Bloomingdale’s // at Zappos
also wearing: EVEREVE Shayla Pullover (M) // Vineyard Vines shorts (8)
Boat shoes are having a moment this spring, and while I’ve never been especially drawn to preppy styles, I was curious to give them a try. They seemed like a practical transition shoe—something a little different from my usual loafers or driving mocs. I ordered a few styles and ended up keeping this pair from Jeffrey Campbell for more casual looks. For some reason, I especially like how they pair with shorts. I haven’t worn them as much as I expected yet, but I’m glad to have them in my closet. Hopefully I’ll reach for them more now that the weather has warmed up here in Philly.
Fit Tip: These run a bit small; I sized up to an 8.5.
Reformation Kyla Boat Shoe in Rum Suede
also wearing: J.Crew New Icon Trench Coat (8) // LOFT stripe sweater (S) // MOTHER Dazzler (30) // FREJA Caroline
I was drawn to this pair as an elevated take on the boat shoe trend; they feel more like a variation on a loafer than a true preppy boat shoe. The color leans a bit too rust for my personal taste, but the quality is excellent, and they’re incredibly comfortable. I expected to reach for them more than I have, but I’m not ready to part with them, either. They work well with a classic straight ankle jean and a nautical-style sweater, as pictured here.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Steve Madden Verdict Mesh Sneaker in Green
at Nordstrom // at DSW // at Macys
also wearing: Caslon Stripe Crewneck Rib Sweater (S) // Vineyard Vines shorts (8)
I wear sneakers probably more than any other shoe, and I’ve amassed quite a collection. These low-profile mesh sneakers are lightweight, breathable, and perfect for spring. I love the slip-on design—easy to throw on and go—and they come in a bunch of great colorways. Bonus: they’re super affordable, too.
Fit tip: These sneakers run true to size, or size up if in between. I have the 8.5.
Gola Viper Sneaker in Bone
also wearing: EVEREVE Bailey Stripe Grommet Sweatshirt (S) // Citizens of Humanity Palma Straight-Leg Jeans (29) // NAGHEDI Nomad Hobo in Cashmere
This low-profile sneaker is incredibly comfortable, and the beige suede is a nice alternative to the traditional white leather sneaker. It still works as a neutral, but the texture and tone give it a slightly more elevated, intentional look. These are great for casual outfits when you want something easy but not too sporty.
Fit Tip: These sneakers run really big—size down at least a half size. I have the 7.5.
Vionic Klara in Camel
at Nordstrom // at Zappos // at DSW // at Amazon
also wearing: EVEREVE Jane Pullover (S) // MOTHER Dazzler Flood Fray (29)
Ballet flats are another classic shoe style having a moment this spring, but they can be tricky for ladies who need support. If that is your situation, you definitely need to try this podiatrist-designed ballet flat with an orthotic footbed and a flexible, cushioned outsole. The squared-off cap toe, dainty bow, and small keyhole cutout add a touch of charm to the classic silhouette, and they are super comfortable and come in tons of colors. I especially like this camel shade; it’s a great neutral that goes with everything.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Schutz Arissa in Brown
at Nordstrom (8)
also wearing: EVEREVE Gia Cowl Neck Top in Folkstone Grey (S) // MOTHER Tomcat in Cream Puffs(30)
These ballet flats are super comfortable—the leather is soft and supple, and I like that they cover a good portion of the toe bed (no “toe cleavage”). They don’t offer much in the way of support, but if that’s not an issue for you, they make a great pair of everyday flats, and they’re under $100.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Schutz Arissa Woven Ballet Flat in Silver
at EVEREVE (8) // more colors at Nordstrom
also wearing: LOFT Bubble Hem Jacket (S) // FRAME tee (XS) // MOTHER Weekender (29)
The silver basketweave version is equally cute and comfortable, and right on trend for spring.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Margaux The Demi Flat in Black
also wearing: Sezane Clyde Trench (6) // MOTHER Dazzler (30) // Quince Cashmere Tee (L) // similar bag
For a more splurge-worthy option, these Margaux ballet flats are truly gorgeous, and I love the slender silhouette with a subtly more substantial sole and 1/2″ heel. They’re handmade in Spain from Italian nappa leather and finished with a classic grosgrain trim. The flexible leather sole, foam-padded insole, and adjustable bow make for a comfortable, customized fit. They feel amazing right out of the box, and they come in medium, wide, and narrow widths—which is always a plus. I have them in black, but I’ve been eyeing the Saddle pair too.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; EU 39 fits me perfectly.
Sam Edelman Bianka Slingback Pump in Buff Tan
at Nordstrom // at Bloomingdale’s // at Zappos
also wearing: Ming Wang Contrast Panel Sheath Dress (S) // similar bag
I already have these classic slingback pumps in another color, and I find them both flattering and comfortable. Even though I don’t wear pumps often, I couldn’t resist adding this raffia version to my spring wardrobe. They’re the perfect dressy transition shoe for when it’s not quite sandal weather. (I wore them on Easter Sunday with the dress shown above.) The slingback style feels a little more modern than a traditional pump, but they serve the same purpose, and I love the subtle texture the raffia adds to an outfit.
Fit tip: They run true to size, or size up if in between. I have the 8.5.
Veronica Beard Via Leather Slide Sandals in Honey
at Bloomingale’s // at Nordstrom // at Shopbop
also wearing: cloth & stone tank (S) // AG Mari jeans (30) // rattan wrapped hoops
These sandals are a bit of a splurge, but they’re probably my most worn new shoes so far this spring—thanks to two back-to-back trips to Florida! It hasn’t been warm enough to wear them much here in Philly yet, but by the end of summer, I’m confident the cost per wear will justify the investment. They’re perfect for elevating casual outfits and pulling together dressier looks for dinners out. The honey brown leather is soft and luxe, the gold studs add a subtle edge, and they’re incredibly comfortable—no break-in period required.
Fit tip: I have these in a size 8, so I’d say they run true to size, or you may want to try a half size up. (I often need a 7.5 in slides.)
Sam Edelman Bambi Raffia Buckle Slide Sandal in Cuoio
at Nordstrom // at Amazon // at Zappos
also wearing: EVEREVE Cecilia Shirred Top (S) // MOTHER Insider (29) // Dragon Diffusion tote
I’m including this pair, even though I technically bought them last spring. I stupidly donated that pair at the end of the season—then they brought them back, and I realized how much I liked them… so I bought them again this year! Yes, they’re that good. I love the raffia texture paired with the feminine scalloped detail, bold tortoiseshell buckle, and polished hardware. Plus, they’re extremely comfortable, with a padded footbed and light cushioning under the strap—and they’re under $100!
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Sam Edelman Cressa Slingback Kitten Heel Sandal
at Nordstrom // at Bloomingdale’s // at Zappos // at Amazon
also wearing: Ming Wang Chain Detail Sheath Dress (S)
I’m never without a pair of strappy black sandals in my summer closet, and this year, these are my go-to. I like how they help bookend a look with a black top or balance out a black dress. They’re comfortable right out of the box—the straps are soft and don’t rub or cause blisters.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Reformation Eleonora Slingback Sandal in Gold
at Nordstrom // at Reformation
also wearing: RAILS dress (more sizes)
I always like to have a pair of metallic heeled sandals in my spring/summer wardrobe because they’re so versatile. These gorgeous leather slingback sandals have a block heel and a strappy, ‘70s-inspired upper, and the squared open toe and slingback strap give them a modern feel. They’re perfect for dressing up denim or pairing with dresses this spring and summer, and they’re extremely comfortable and high quality.
Fit Tip: These sandals run true to size; I have the 8.
Schutz Taliah Mid Woven Heel
c/o EVEREVE // at Bloomingdale’s
also wearing: Alex Mill Alexis Linen Cotton Dress c/o (M)
EVEREVE sent me these heels as part of our dress collab, and I’m excited to have them in my spring lineup. They’re the perfect “barely there” heeled sandal—ideal for wearing with dresses or dressing up a denim look for date night.
Fit Tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
PAIGE Jill Ankle Strap Espadrille Platform Wedge Sandal in Mahogany
also wearing: EVEREVE Camp Jacket (M) // RAILS Arlene (S) // MOTHER Roller (29) (option)
My newest shoe purchase, and probably my favorite! These platform wedge sandals are perfect for pairing with full-length jeans that need a bit of height. The intertwined leather straps are so pretty (and soft!), and the platform makes the 2¼” heel feel totally walkable. No rubbing, no blisters—just a sleek, comfortable fit. They’re a bit of a splurge, but I’m confident the cost per wear will balance out over time.
Fit tip: These run true to size; I have the 8.
Stay In Touch
If you liked this post, be sure you’re signed up for my email newsletter. In addition to my most recent blog posts, you’ll receive exclusive newsletter content like special sales, my newest favorite finds, and an occasional peek behind the scenes — all delivered right to your inbox.
I would also love for you to join my JLS Fashion Insiders Facebook Group! This is a friendly place to discuss all matters of fashion and style with other women, share your outfits, get advice, and stay up to date on all the happenings in our community.
20 Responses
I really like the Paige platform wedge, but they do not offer alternative widths (and they are out of my price range). I’ll have to keep an eye out for similar styles that offer widths.
This is a great compilation of spring shoes! Considering you have had some foot issues, I’d like to suggest a post on stylish, comfort shoes from Kuru, Orthofeet, & The Walking Company. I’ve recently developed plantar fasciitis in my right heel, & all of my cute, less supportive shoes are sitting forlorn in my closet. I’d appreciate your help in deciding what shoes to order!
Do you have any issue with the Schutz Arissa styles being way too big in the back and slipping off your heel? I love this style and the colors but I even tried a size down but then they were two short.
No, they fit great. Which is odd b/c I thought I had narrow heels. Maybe not so much now that I’ve had all those ankle injuries. My ankles are permanently swollen, it seems.
Not shoe-related, but you look amazing in that turquoise dress. Really flattering and makes you look super tan!
Thank you!
I like the brown wedge sandals. I’ve only added 3 shoes all sandals. I’m looking for a black wedge 2 inch heel more on the casual side like the brown ones you’re wearing. And I’m not splurging. Lol. I’m going to try not to do recreational shopping like Jen suggested. I’m guilty. When I went to Marshalls the other day I just looked at the shoes to see if they had leather ones in named brands. They didn’t but I did find a raffia bag with black trim. The Quince article yesterday was very interesting. I’m still buying from them. The cotton sweaters and dress I have are good quality. They’re not pilling which is my pet peeve. I think there’s a lot of stealing of ideas in fashion anyway. Cyndi styled Quince jeans but unfortunately they are out of stock so I’m on wait-list.
I forgot to add this. If you don’t wear your shoes often, they may fall apart when you decide to wear them. It’s happened to me three times. It’s happened to other people I know too. I think in most cases it’s not wearing them for years or in my case a year. I have some boots I didn’t wear this past year so I may have to put an extra pair in my car next winter if I decide to wear them. I’m thinking of just wearing around the house some of my dress shoes I don’t wear often. Jo-Lynn you don’t have to worry about it though. 😊
Wow Terri that is such an interesting theory! Now that I think about it, I can definitely see it. I have had more than one pair of shoes break after only being worn a time or two, but then not being worn for many months or even a year – especially special occasion shoes. And often well made brands that shouldn’t have broken quickly! Great suggestion to wear them around the house for a little while!
For Virginia, you might want to try Dolce Vita’s ballet flat. They are same styling and price point but are better quality than Schutz. I have found that Schutz shies are not the quality of Sam Edelman and Dolce Vita or even Seychelles. All are better and same price point.
I’m a little mad at myself for not trying the Paige wedges when I was with you. I love them on you. What was I thinking?
LOL! I’m sure they’re still there!
You have a very versatile shoe collection. I really do wish that the PAIGE Jill Ankle Strap Espadrille Platform Wedge Sandal and the Sam Edelman Bambi Raffia Buckle Slide Sandal were available in narrow and had arch support. Since I’m far from lacking in shoe options, it’s probably a good thing they don’t. 😉
Love shoes but my closet is soooooo full. Trying right now to wear the ones I have or really figure out what I’m missing.
Love your shoe selections and comments. This is a Loft question – has anyone else noticed a change in the quality of merchandise in the Loft stores? For the past month or so I feel like I’m shopping at Marshalls, Ross or TJ Maxx (not to disparage those stores, but not of the same caliber as J. Crew, Banana, Evereve, or Nordstrom). The sales associates are also new and quite a bit younger (like you would find in Urban Outfitters). I’m in Northern CA. Wondering if anyone else has observed this change or if it’s just this one store? TIA
Hi, Jolynn, why do you replace your shoes every season? Are they not made well enough to last? Thank you.
Due to my business of running this blog, I try to keep the majority of my wardrobe current so I can link what I’m wearing. 🙂
Ah, that makes sense! Thank you!
I just bought a pair of tan/light beige coloured slip on Birkenstocks. I wear them with sweat pants and jeans. They aren’t very feminine looking, but they are so easy to wear. Are they totally out of style?
Not at all! I still wear mine.