Where to Stay in Lancaster County: Willow Valley Family Resort

We live within an hour of Lancaster County, so we are no stranger to the sites and attractions. Over the years we have taken family day trips to see plays, tour Amish villages and visit farms and orchards. I often trek out to Lancaster to meet up with friends and shop at the infamous outlets located there.

More recently I have discovered some small farms that are great sources of locally grown and produced foods. But until last weekend, I had never before actually stayed overnight in Lancaster County.

Our family was invited to spend two nights at the Willow Valley — a family resort located between downtown Lancaster and the Amish farmlands.

lancaster county countryside

I know, right? How incredibly gorgeous is that!? It was the PERFECT fall weekend. Honestly I couldn’t have asked for better weather. It was cool but not cold, crisp and breezy, and sunny with only perfectly puffy white clouds to break up the blue skies.

Willow Valley has two parts — Willow Valley Inn & Suites and the Doubletree Resort by Hilton, which is a newer building with room for conferences and meetings. We stayed at the Doubletree. Outside it is fairly unassuming, but the inside is elegant.

When we arrived, we were greeted by friendly hotel staff and their signature chocolate chip cookies. Unfortunately my son is allergic to nuts, and I don’t eat gluten, so only three of us were able to partake. The cookies are a nice touch, but in this day and age of food allergies, I have to wonder why they don’t have any other options available — especially with kids involved. It’s really hard to see the other siblings happily nibbling on chocolate chip cookies while going without. But that was just a minor blemish upon arrival, and my son took it in stride. The staff was welcoming and accomodating, and soon we were headed down the hall to our room to get settled in.

willow valley resort
photo credit:

The family room was spacious with 2 queen beds and a pull-out couch, so the room easily accommodated our family of five. (Why do more hotels not offer this!!?? It is so hard to travel as a family of five or six, and yet we are not uncommon.)

The bathroom was small, but there was an additional vanity just outside the bathroom, so two people could be getting ready at the same time — always a welcome feature in a hotel room. Again, I don’t know why they aren’t all designed that way.

The decor was nice, if a bit tired. All in all, it was comfortable and welcoming.

We arrived at dinnertime and had planned to eat at Cafe 24 Hundred, the restaurant on site. According to the website, they specialize in locally sourced seasonal menus, which as you know is right up my alley! They also advertised locally brewed beers and fine wine, so we were eager to try it out.

It wasn’t quite as posh as we were expecting. It was small and homey, though, and the waitstaff was superb. I was just bummed that it was too cool to eat on the deck. The view of the property is breathtaking.

photo credit:

After reading about locally brewed beers and fine wine, we were surprised that there was only one locally brewed beer and only about 5 wine selections — all from the same brand and priced identically at $5.50 a glass. I was expecting a more extensive wine and beer list, and maybe some more premium wine brands, but I happily sipped on an ice-cold pinot grigio (lukewarm white wine is one of my many pet peeves, but this was perfectly chilled) and as far as I know my husband enjoyed his beer.

The children’s menu was pretty typical kid fare, without a single vegetable, I might add, so my kids ordered from the adult menu. My girls chose the baked potato soup and a Casear salad, and they both gobbled up every morsel.

When they brought the dinner rolls,they contained sesame — and my son is allergic. He also happens to love bread. Fortunately the server was right on top of it, and she came back within minutes with a slab of french bread for him. I was thrilled that they had another option, and that she thought to bring it to him without our asking. The service more than made up for any disappointment in the menu.

My favorite part of the dinner, by far, was The 24 Hundred Market Salad — baby spinach, shaved red onion, balsamic macerated strawberries, candied pecans, bacon nuggets (yes, NUGGETS of BACON, be still my beating heart) and creamy goat cheese dressing. It. Was. Divine. I wish I had a photo but I was too busy gobbling it down to reach for my camera phone. I would go back just for that.

As for our entrees, my son ordered pasta with meat sauce and was pleased. My husband and I both opted for the special that night — pork tenderloins. The presentation was lovely, and they appeared to be cooked to perfection, as you could see they were even a bit pink in the middle, but the flavor and texture were disappointing. We agreed that it was likely the quality of meat, not the chef, that was to blame.

In looking back at the menu today, I can see that they specialize in steaks, and I am wondering why I didn’t notice The 24 Hundred Burger — Ironstone Spring Farm, grass-fed beef and applewood smoked bacon with cheese. Now THAT sounds delicious. In fact, here’s a photo I found on their site.

photo credit:

Oh well, live and learn. (And don’t order the special! lol)

After dinner, we were eager to visit their indoor pool and water playground that we had heard so much about. It’s hard to stay in a hotel with kids when there’s nothing to do after dinner. It can be a looong night, in my limited experience — limited because I choose not to stay in hotels with my entire family unless I have to.

But in this case, we had no problem occupying our time. Long story short, we could hardly get our kids out of the pool all weekend long. It certainly isn’t a water park to rival Great Wolf Lodge or the ilk, but it was big enough for all my kids to enjoy, and with our range of ages, that’s saying a lot.

Last summer, we were disappointed with the way the pools at the Hyatt Chesapeake Bay didn’t have an area shallow enough for our 5-year-old daughter to stand and play confidently. But on the other hand, we were afraid the Willow Valley pool may be too babyish for my son.

On the contrary, all three of our kids had a great time. There was plenty to do with lots of room to chase each other around, and the slide was super fast; even my 11-year-old son loved it.

And the adult pool was 3 feet in its shallowest part, so all three kids could enjoy swimming and playing over there as well, which they did.

Willow Valley Adult Pool
photo credit:

Even I had a place to call my own. Waaaay back in the far corner is a hot tub, and I wasted no time making my way over there and giving it a whirl. Haha, whirl? Get it? Oh I slay me.

And no, there are no photos. Are ya crazy??

The pool sufficiently tired everyone out, so we returned to our room for night.

Stay tuned for Family Weekend in Lancaster County, Day 2!

Join the Conversation

19 thoughts on “Where to Stay in Lancaster County: Willow Valley Family Resort

  1. I have stayed there many times and I agree with you on your points. My husband’s employer puts on a retreat there every year in JANUARY! (Ugh, there is nothing to do in January!) The place is nice and I think that this year my children will be able to enjoy the waterpark/pool area more than in previous years. I live 40 minutes from Lancaster now and loving being over there. Looking forward to more of your adventures there. Thanks for sharing.

  2. Ah, thank you for the flashback. 🙂 As I told you a few days ago in a comment, we’ve gone there every year for 20 some years growing up, and my husband and I had our reception in the Palm Court. We love, love, love Willow Valley but must admit we haven’t been there in a few years (other than brunch at the Palm Court on Sunday – DE-LISH) to stay overnight. Must get that on the agenda soon. I have many fond memories growing up in that pool, going to the bakery, feeding the ducks at the pond, and on and on. Glad you could enjoy it! 🙂

    1. The Palm Court – I don’t remember reading about that. Someone told me to stay away from the smorgasbord, so I did, lol. I saw the bakery but didn’t go in. I would have, probably, but the gluten-free thing keeps me away from bakeries these days. And we got plenty of goodies on our bus tour, so we really didn’t need any more sweets.

      1. No, not the smorgasboard. That’s just “eh.” This is an AMAZING brunch on Sundays (pretty expensive) that pretty much takes up the entire Palm Court. Voted the best in Lancaster County all the time! Sooo good! I wonder if they don’t have it anymore?!?! I hope they still do. 🙂

  3. My family had family renunions there every year when i was growing up! It was always a lot of fun. They had the indoor pools but not the water park- looks like they have spruced things up quite a bit!

  4. We are headed here Saturday. I am so gald to see your review. I wonder if the beer/wine thing is because they only started serving alcohol in the last several years? I believe (someone may be able to verify this) they were an alcohol-free hotel until recently. Wasn’t sure about the cafe- bad reviews on tripadvisor. We may just skip the Cafe and get a pizza!

    1. Yes, that is true. When they applied for a Doubletree franchise, then they started serving alcohol. It tasted fine (I went for pinot grigio b/c it is hard to find a bad pino grigio, lol) and as I said, was appropriately ice cold, so I really can’t complain. I just thought they rather oversold themselves in their promotional materials.

      The cafe is really okay, again, I think they oversell it and make it sound more unique than it is. For hotel food, it’s fine. And please remember, we are very picky about our food. So most people would probably be pleased. I didn’t read reviews about it – that would be interesting.

  5. Sorry if this may seem a little off topic for this post, but I just had to ask where you typically get clothes for your girls? The outfits they have on in the pictures at the end are adorable! I have a 4 1/2 year old and I’m struggling this fall to find her some nicer outfits.

    1. Caroline’s dress and leggins are from Target, and Rebecca’s little outfit is from the Osh Kosh Factory Outlet. 🙂 I don’t spend a lot for kids’ clothes because they wreck them.

      My girls are very picky about how things feel. The little one won’t wear jeans at all. She will only wear leggings that are skin-tight so I buy a lot of tunics and dresses for her. The older one will wear more things, but I get all her jeans at Gap b/c they are the only ones she seems to tolerate. They both like dresses, but it’s harder and harder to find nice looking dresses as they get older. I love Osh Kosh, and outlet prices are reasonable.

  6. I live Fl, and enjoyed this first segment as a little online escape. I love the pics of your kids. They are so cute, and your little one ‘hams’ it up like my oldest son does when in front of a camera. I don’t always comment, but I do always enjoy the honesty of your posts. Thanks for bringing us along for a virtual vacation!

  7. We love Willow Valley and the outlets out there are fun, too!
    When I go with the girlfriends we stay at a cute bed and breakfast called the Apple Bin Inn. Great food and the Innkeepers are so sweet.
    We love it out there.

Want More?

Jo-Lynne Shane on Instagram

Click an image below.

Follow @jolynneshane